cover of the ambitious kitchen cookbook
The Ambitious Kitchen Cookbook
A New York Times Bestseller

Iced Cherry Toasted Almond Oatmeal Cookies

Chewy almond oatmeal cookies made with brown sugar and toasted, sliced almonds then topped with a perfectly sweet cherry icing. These beautiful cherry almond oatmeal cookies have a splash of amaretto for extra flavor, and can easily be made both gluten-free and dairy-free. Share these delicious, unique cookies with friends and family this holiday season!

Prep Time
30 mins
Cook Time
50 mins
Total Time
1 hour 20 mins

This post may contain affiliate links, which means that I make a small commission off items you purchase at no additional cost to you. Please read my policy page.

Shop This Post

Leave a comment & rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rating:




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Show comments Hide comments
  • says:

    5 stars
    These were fabulous! So flavorful

    • replied:

      Glad you enjoyed!!

  • says:

    I’ve tried twice and failed at these cookies. Should they be chilled? My cookies spread too big, were flat, and crispy. Then the icing never set and it was pink at first and by the next day it turned blue/purple and looked moldy (they were stored in air tight containers). Would love to know what I could adjust bc they sound like a great cookie but this recipe is not executing as written.

    • replied:

      Hi! I’m not sure what’s going on but this recipe has been tested 4 times by professional testers including myself. I’m wondering if you weighted the ingredients? Also was your butter melted or softened? did you use rolled oats or quick oats? You used the proper almonds amount? I haven’t had an issue with the icing at all, and mold wouldn’t appear that quickly. It sounds like perhaps you may have added too much milk to the icing so it didn’t set. I’m going to retest these again soon and report back!

  • says:

    3 stars
    I liked the cookies, but the icing was very disappointing- it did not have much of a cherry flavor (what I was looking forward to the most) and the recipe did not make enough for all of the cookies. I put just the smallest drizzle on and one third of my cookies didn’t have any.

    • replied:

      Hi! I’m so sorry you had an issue. Did you weigh your ingredients? 150g of cherries and 170g of powdered sugar should make plenty of frosting for all of the cookies. In terms of cherry flavor, you could add chopped dried cherries to the dough next time!

  • says:

    4 stars
    A fun oatmeal cookie variation. Great addition of color and flavors for holiday cookie boxes. Baked the first handful per instructions, and they spread an absurd amount. But I was able to scoot them together with a biscuit cutter. Threw the rest in the fridge to chill and found an at least 15 minute chill was ideal with a baking time on the longer end. Using 2 tablespoon scoops made 20 cookies and a lil baby cookie.

    • replied:

      Hi! I’m glad they turned out well after being chilled, but I’d love to help troubleshoot. Did you by chance weigh your ingredients?

  • says:

    I am not having luck with these cookies. I maked the dough exactly as the recipe states and the cookies were very flat/thin. I remade and chillded the dough for 30 minutes and they stayed thicker but browned too much on the bottom. Will try one more time and then I am giving up…..was going to take these to a cookie exchange but even if the last batch works I will not have enough.

    • replied:

      Hi! So sorry to hear that these are giving you trouble — are you weighing your ingredients? I had multiple different people on my team test these, and they all turned out perfectly after weighing, so I’m suspecting that might be the culprit!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These cookies are incredible! I didn’t have amaretto and skipped it, and I still found that they had plenty of almond flavor. Will be adding these permanently to the Christmas cookie rotation!

    • replied:

      Perfect! So happy to hear that!

You might also like

maple roasted turkey on a platter on a thanksgiving table
Your stress-free Thanksgiving starts here
Your stress-free Thanksgiving starts here

Get my FREE 3-part email series with my Thanksgiving menu (+ grocery list!), prep & hosting tips, and a relaxing day-of timeline.

 

Get my Thanksgiving menu (+ grocery list!), prep tips, and an easy day-of timeline.