cover of the ambitious kitchen cookbook
The Ambitious Kitchen Cookbook
A New York Times Bestseller

Incredible Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies

Amazing oatmeal cream pies with a gingerbread twist! These perfectly spiced gingerbread sandwich cookies are crispy on the outside, soft in the center, and filled with a delicious thick cream middle for the ultimate holiday cookie.

Prep Time
1 hour 30 mins
Cook Time
10 mins
Total Time
1 hour 40 mins

This post may contain affiliate links, which means that I make a small commission off items you purchase at no additional cost to you. Please read my policy page.

Shop This Post

Leave a comment & rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rating:




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Show comments Hide comments
  • says:

    5 stars
    Best Holiday cookies! Always a hit. Perf baking time for me is 12 min.

  • says:

    Can you substitute old fashioned molasses for the black strap molasses?

    • replied:

      That will work! The cookies may just be a bit sweeter and have a more subtle molasses flavor.

  • says:

    I look forward to making this cookie at Christmas all year long. I honestly didn’t even think I would be into the flavor combo but it HITS SO HARD YALL

    • replied:

      So good!! Glad you love it!

  • says:

    5 stars
    would these work with gluten free 1:1 flour?

    • replied:

      sorry, just noticed this has already been asked!

      • replied:

        No problem! I haven’t tested it, but I think it might work!

  • says:

    I liked these! The color of mine didn’t turn out quite as dark, (even using blackstrap molasses), more of a medium brown, so FYI for anyone for whom the color is important. I also wound up baking them for a few more minutes than the recipe, which might be my oven, but FYI they seem hard to overbake, they turned out quite soft even with a longer baketime. I also used a cream cheese filling since I’m all about the tang. The sandwiches softened up nicely after an hour of being filled, as promised–really nice texture with the oats, and they got multiple compliments at a party. thanks!

    • replied:

      So glad you enjoyed! Such a great treat for parties & gatherings this time of year 🙂

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are delicious! I used 1:1 GF flour and couldn’t tell a difference. My husband loved them.

    • replied:

      Perfect! Glad you both enjoyed.

  • says:

    5 stars
    Question… can I mix the cream filling by hand? I don’t have an electric mixer. And can the cream sit in the fridge overnight before using? Thanks!

    • replied:

      Yes and yes! You’ll just need to whip it together really well.

  • says:

    5 stars
    Question… can I mix the dough and cream filling by hand? I don’t have an electric mixer. Thanks!

  • says:

    Hey how can I store these in the freezer once assembled.

    • replied:

      Hi! Check out the full post, which has storing & freezing instructions 🙂

  • I have more of a question than a comment. I want to make these this year for my holiday gift-giving. How do you think it would work if I used cream cheese in lieu of butter for the filling?

    • replied:

      For a cream cheese frosting I typically use a mix of butter and cream cheese to get the right flavor!

  • says:

    5 stars
    I was able to make these gluten free AND vegan with Namaste all purpose flour, country crock plant butter sticks, and “just egg”. I needed a little extra flour to keep the body for turning them into sandwiches but they turned out great and were a hit even with my no-allergy friends! I would probably use Bob’s Red Mill AP flour next time.

    • replied:

      I’m glad those swaps worked out well!

  • says:

    5 stars
    My husband and I loved these! I am wondering though, is there a way to make them less sweet? They were quite rich and sweet for our liking, any tips would be greatly appreciated!

    • replied:

      Glad these are a favorite! I’d suggest reducing the powdered sugar a bit in the icing, or even icing the cookies individually instead of sandwiching them 🙂

  • says:

    5 stars
    These were AMAZING! I loved the Little Debbie oatmeal cream pies growing up and knew I needed to try these for Christmas. I subbed Bob’s Red Mill GF One to One flour and they turned out perfect!

    • replied:

      The best! Happy to hear the GF flour worked, too!

  • says:

    5 stars
    Incredibly good. Don’t be afraid to spoon on a big heap of the frosting, there’s plenty for the recipe.

  • says:

    5 stars
    I doubled the recipe because I was certain it would be delicious. The cookies are amazing – crisp edges but chewy. When I make next time,
    I am going to skip the buttercream and just use marshmallow cream or Fluff. The buttercream is just too sweet for me. But this is a terrific recipe!

    • replied:

      Perfect! These are great for customizing with your fav frosting 🙂

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are absolutely amazing.. Followed recipe to a T and wouldn’t change a thing. Will make again for sure!

    • replied:

      So happy to hear that!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are a 100 out of 10! I made these THREE years ago and I STILL get asked for the recipe 😂 I made them for a cookie swap and ended up giving some to neighbors and friends. Solid recipe. LOVE!

    • replied:

      Two years ago***

      • replied:

        Amazing!! So glad you’ve loved them all these years!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are hands down the best cookies! 5 ⭐️ and loved by adults and kids. I made these with my 8 year old daughter, they are relatively simple but look and taste gourmet. We followed the recipe and used a cookie scoop to make even sized cookie balls. Highly recommend!

    • replied:

      Perfect! Such a great holiday cookie 🙂

    • replied:

      5 stars
      I’ve made these multiple times and they were a HUGE hit. Definitely my favorite Christmas cookie!!

      Question- if I left out the spices would this be just like the original Little Debbie oatmeal cream pies? (But better of course since they are homemade!)

      • replied:

        So happy to hear that! They will still have a slight “gingerbread” flavor from the molasses, but they’ll be closer to that original Little Debbie flavor 🙂

  • says:

    5 stars
    Made your recipe several times and it is always a hit with everyone, especially adults! I add lemon zest to the filling and a bit more powdered sugar and cream to get a fluffy soft filling. Lemon and gingerbread are such a great combination. Thanks for a favorite recipe I make over and over!

    • replied:

      Amazing! LOVE the idea of adding lemon!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are amazing!! Made exactly as recipe states, although I did not have all spice so added a little nutmeg and cloves. Every single one gone by the end of the day!

    • replied:

      Perfect swap! So glad you loved them!

  • says:

    World this work with molasses that’s not blackstrap? Thank you!

    • replied:

      Hi! Yes, it should – the flavor will just be a bit lighter.

  • says:

    This coolie recipe is amazing 100/10 rating my kids love these definitely recommend trying this cookie

    • replied:

      Ahhh yay! Glad these cookies are a hit for everyone!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These oatmeal cream pies were amazing. Next time I need to make the filling thicker; it melted a little and oozed out the sides, even after the cookies cooled. Keeping them in the fridge fixes this issue tho. I didn’t use gluten-free flour but did use gluten-free rolled oats, as that is all I had on hand. This didn’t make a difference in the texture.

    • replied:

      Perfect! I am so glad you enjoyed this recipe and it turned out great for you 🙂

  • says:

    I used King Arthur gluten free Measure for Measure to make this recipe and they were delicious. The crucial step that is absolutely imperative is to chill the dough so you don’t end up with a gritty texture.

    • replied:

      Ah yay! I am so glad this recipe turned out great for you Karla. Thanks for your review, I appreciate it!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are delicious!! I made them for the first time for Christmas and everyone loved them! I’ve made them exactly as the recipe calls and also made them once- swapping the milk with eggnog for the filling. Both ways were incredible!!

    • replied:

      Excellent! so glad this recipe is a hit, love the eggnog idea, sounds delish!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These cookies are amazing and a huge hit with everyone. So many people asked for the recipe!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These were delicious! The blackstrap molasses gives a stronger flavor than traditional ginger snaps, but I loved it. I used some oat flour in place of some of the all purpose flour and Truvia brown sugar, and they turned out great!

  • says:

    5 stars
    The absolute best cookies!!! Everyone needs to make these!

  • says:

    5 stars
    These are sooo good! We left them out for Santa and my son was sure they would be the best cookies Santa got all night! He was right ❤️

  • says:

    5 stars
    These look amazing! Love a ginger cookie!

  • says:

    These are absolutely incredible. To die for. Dangerously delicious. I made these GF using Bobs Red Mill 1 to 1 baking flour. It is very important to cool in fridge before baking as instructed in recipe or they will flatten out more. You don’t want this. This is my favorite cookie recipe of Ambitious Kitchen. #AKcookieparty

  • says:

    5 stars
    These turned out so good. This will be on repeat in my house. Thanks for a great recipe.

You might also like

monique volz of ambitious kitchen at a holiday table with text overlay
Shop our holiday gift guides

We curated thoughtful gift ideas across 7 gift guides to make shopping a breeze! From parents to friends & even giving back -- there's something for everyone.